The Fair Play Award is presented to the nation that finishes with the best disciplinary record, devised from a formula accounting for accumulated fouls, yellow and red cards.
| Year | Winner |
| 1991 | Mexico |
| 1993 | Not awarded |
| 1996 | Not awarded |
| 1998 | Not awarded |
| 2000 | Canada |
| 2002 | Costa Rica |
| 2003 | United States |
| 2005 | Honduras |
| 2007 | Honduras |
| 2009 | United States |
| 2011 | Mexico |
