The Best Goalkeeper Award is selected by the Tournament Awards Committee.
| Year | Winner | Team |
| 2000 | Craig Forrest | Canada |
| 2002 | Not awarded | |
| 2003 | Not awarded | |
| 2005 | Jaime Penedo | Panama |
| 2007 | Franck Grandel | Guadeloupe |
| 2009 | Keilor Navas | Costa Rica |
| 2011 | Noel Valladares | Honduras |
